Lagoon vs Bali - which catamaran should you choose?

Lagoon or Bali? The Bali door and solid foredeck vs bow nets and flybridges, lengths and cabins of common charter models, and which catamaran suits whom.

A young woman on a pier looks at two differently shaped catamarans, question marks above her head, wondering which to choose

If you're looking at catamarans for a sailing week, two names come up fast: Lagoon and Bali. Both are French, both build comfortable cruising catamarans, and you'll have a great week at sea on either. But they aren't the same, and you feel the difference the moment you step on board.

If you've already settled sailboat or catamaran in favour of the catamaran, the brand is usually the next question. Here we compare what a guest actually notices when choosing a catamaran for a holiday in Greece: how the space is laid out, where you sit and sunbathe, where the helm is, and which boat suits whom.

Who builds Lagoon and who builds Bali?

Lagoon has been building catamarans since 1984 and is now part of the French Groupe Beneteau. The hulls are drawn by VPLP Design, a studio known for racing multihulls, the exterior by Patrick le Quément, Renault's former head of design, and the interiors by the Italian studio Nauta. Lagoon says its boats are designed “from the interior to the exterior”, with simplicity and reliability as the goal.

By the builder's own count, about 7,700 Lagoon catamarans sail around the world, and around 900 of the older Lagoon 450 alone were delivered. Lagoon also has a long record in charter: its models are designed for owners and charter alike.

Bali is the younger brand. The concept dates from 2014, it was created by Olivier Poncin, and the brand belongs to the French Catana Group, known for the faster, sportier Catana catamarans. From the start, Bali built its name on one idea: open the boat to the sea as much as possible, so the inside and outside become one space.

What makes a Bali different?

A catamaran saloon with the rear door fully open so saloon and cockpit become one open space
  • The Bali door. The back wall of the saloon is really a large door that tilts up and slides under the ceiling. When it's open, the saloon and the aft cockpit become one big space, which Bali calls the Open Space. It opens with hydraulic assistance, by hand or at the push of a button depending on the model. Bali says the door isn't part of the boat's structure, so it can stay open under sail when the weather allows.
  • A door to the bow. On models such as the 4.2, 4.4 and 4.6, a separate door takes you from the saloon and galley straight out to the bow, without walking around the deckhouse.
  • A solid foredeck instead of nets. Most catamarans have nets (trampolines) between the hulls at the bow, but Bali doesn't. Instead there's a solid deck with a forward cockpit, cushions for lounging and a shade awning for the anchorage. Bali points out that the whole area is fenced by a railing and that the boat stays drier, because no water sprays up through the nets.
  • A flybridge on the roof. Every Bali model except the smallest (the Catsmart) has an upper deck on the saloon roof. On the 4.2 and 4.4 the helm is up there too, right next to the sun loungers, so whoever wants to watch the sailing sits up top with the skipper.

What makes a Lagoon different?

A catamaran at anchor with tall saloon windows, a bow net and the helm on a raised upper deck
  • A classic layout. The aft cockpit and the saloon are connected by a door but stay two separate spaces: a terrace outside and a living room inside.
  • Nets at the bow. Like most catamarans, a Lagoon has nets between the hulls, where you can lie just above the water. On models such as the Lagoon 46 there's also a seating area in front of the saloon, so the bow works for both sitting and lying down.
  • Upright windows. You recognise a Lagoon by its deckhouse with upright windows. In practice that means a little more room inside and less direct sun in the saloon, which you notice in a Greek summer.
  • The helm and flybridge. On smaller models such as the Lagoon 42, the helm sits on the back wall of the deckhouse, right by the cockpit, so the skipper is in touch with the crew the whole time. On larger models such as the Lagoon 46 and 51, the helm is up on the flybridge, with the wheel in the centre and seating around it.

How big are Lagoon and Bali models and how many cabins do they have?

Charter boats aren't always the newest models, so the list also includes some that the builders have since replaced or updated. Length is the boat's length overall, according to the builder.

Lagoon

  • Lagoon 40: 12.75 m, 3 or 4 cabins (the 4-cabin version has 2 or 4 bathrooms)
  • Lagoon 42: 13.22 m, 3 or 4 cabins
  • Lagoon 46: 14.5 m, 3 or 4 cabins
  • Lagoon 50: 14.75 m, 3, 4 or 6 cabins
  • Lagoon 51: 15.6 m, 4 or 6 cabins

Bali

  • Bali Catspace: 12.33 m, 3 or 4 cabins, each with its own bathroom
  • Bali 4.2: 12.86 m, 3 or 4 cabins, each with its own bathroom
  • Bali 4.4: 13.5 m, 3 or 4 cabins, each with its own bathroom
  • Bali 4.6: 14.33 m, 3 to 5 cabins, with 3 or 4 bathrooms

Charter also has older models that are no longer in the builders' current range, such as the Bali 4.8 or the Lagoon 450. The same applies to them as to the newer ones: the brand's traits stay, and you check the layout on the specific boat.

Who is a Bali better for, and who is a Lagoon better for?

A catamaran often carries a bigger group, so where everyone spends the day matters more than it seems.

A Bali is a good choice if...

  • you like being together all the time: while someone cooks, the others sit at the cockpit table and the conversation never stops
  • at anchor you'd rather lie on the bow, with the galley just a few steps away through the forward door
  • you're travelling with children, since Bali argues a fenced, solid foredeck is easier to keep an eye on than nets
  • you want an upper deck with the helm on the roof, where you can see all around the boat

A Lagoon is a good choice if...

  • you like a clear split between the saloon inside and the terrace outside
  • you dream of lying on the nets above the water, which a Bali doesn't have
  • you'd enjoy a shadier saloon in the summer heat
  • on a bigger boat you want a flybridge with the wheel in the centre, and on a smaller one you want the skipper right by the cockpit

Neither choice is wrong. The Bali door closes when the wind picks up, and on a Lagoon you spend the whole day outside too, in the sun and in the sea.

Does the brand matter more than the boat itself?

The skipper and the crew on the pier inspecting the catamaran itself, its cockpit and engine compartment, rather than a brochure, because the boat matters more than the brand

No. In charter, the specific boat tells you more than the name on the hull, and three things make a bigger difference than Lagoon versus Bali:

  • Year of build. Both builders update their models regularly. Lagoon has since replaced the 42 and 46 with new versions, and the new Lagoon 47 got a door between the saloon and the forward cockpit, something Bali has had for years. Over time the two brands are getting closer.
  • Layout. A four-cabin Lagoon 40 can have two or four bathrooms, and for a group of eight that matters more than the name on the hull. The number of cabins and bathrooms depends on the catamaran model and version, not the brand.
  • Equipment. A generator, a watermaker (a unit that makes fresh water from seawater) and air conditioning depend on the boat, not the brand. What a specific boat has is listed in the boat's details or in your offer.

So when you choose a boat from the yacht catalogue or an offer, look at the year, layout and equipment first, and the brand second.

Frequently asked questions

1Which is bigger, the Lagoon 42 or the Bali 4.2?
The Lagoon 42 is slightly longer: 13.22 m against 12.86 m for the Bali 4.2, according to the builders. The numbers in the names aren't exact measurements, so always compare the length overall and the layout in the boat's details.
2Can the Bali door stay open while we sail?
Yes, when the weather allows, because according to the builder the door isn't part of the boat's structure. Whether it stays open is the skipper's call, depending on the wind and waves.
3Is a Lagoon or a Bali better for a first sailing week?
Both are a good choice for a first sailing week, because the skipper handles the boat. Guests are only asked to help with the lines when mooring in some harbours, and the skipper explains it at the start of every week.
4Where do you sunbathe on a Bali without nets?
On the solid foredeck with its cushions and on the flybridge on the saloon roof. At anchor, the foredeck can also be shaded with an awning.
5Do Lagoon or Bali catamarans have air conditioning and a generator?
It depends on the specific boat, not the brand. Whether a boat has air conditioning, a generator or a watermaker is listed in the boat's details or in your offer.

Your week

Not sure which catamaran to choose?

Tell us how many of you there are and what matters most to you on board, and we'll find a catamaran that fits you together, whatever the brand.

Send an inquiry